Highland advisory board debate
The case for professionalising the DDaT workforce has been made for a decade; and received a boost with the 10-Year Health Plan’s mandate for registration with FEDIP.
But what are the practical challenges to progress? And how can digital use this agenda to secure the attention of policy makers and boards? Highland’s panel of NHS and industry experts discussed the issues with former NHS CIO and professionalism advocate Will Smart.
The case for professionalising the NHS digital workforce has been made for more than a decade, but it was given a boost in the 10-Year Health Plan, which included a “mandate” for registration.
Will Smart, the former NHS chief information officer, who has worked on both the trust and the supplier side over his career, told the Highland advisory board the initial push had been “defensive.”
“We started from the position that we wanted to be a profession to have equal standing with doctors and nurses,” he said. “I think that was quite negative, and what matters now is that we want to be recognised for our role in transforming organisations.
“It’s not just about rolling out an EPR or implementing AI. We have a key role in patient safety and operational safety. We need to make sure our expertise is recognised, and professionalisation can help us to achieve that.”
A complex landscape
Will had brought along a definition of a profession to work with: ‘A body of qualified practitioners, working in a particular field’ who are ‘governed by an independent, professional body, that sets standards of practice.’
So, who makes sure that the NHS’ digital, data and technology workers are qualified and suitably experienced and who governs them?
Back in 2016, when health secretary Jeremy Hunt was looking to invest in a “paperless” NHS, he commissioned a US academic, Bob Wachter, to investigate why earlier IT programmes had failed.
Among other issues, Wachter said there was a need to invest in workforce capacity and digital leadership. The government followed up with a plan to grow the DDaT workforce and establish an NHS Digital Academy.
It also backed the development of two organisations: the Faculty for Health Informatics and the Federation for Informatics Professionals in Health and Social Care, or FEDIP.
The Faculty is now hosted by BCS: The Chartered Institute for IT, and Will, who is a fellow, said it is focusing on three projects: to create a community “where people can meet like-minded people”; to drive the professionalism agenda; and to provide that expert voice in policy making.
FEDIP, meanwhile, holds the public register for DDaT professionals – the one the 10-Year Health Plan wants everybody to join, starting with senior leaders. However, it doesn’t set standards for competence, professional development, or behaviour.
These are set by the BCS and other professional bodies; although FEDIP works to make sure they are aligned, so once people have joined one of these bodies, they can also join the register at the right level.
Start, early
The landscape is complex. Highland advisory board chair Nicola Haywood-Cleverly, who is a fellow of the BCS, described her own experience of the “cross registration” between professional bodies and FEDIP as “clunky” and not especially easy to navigate.
She suggested this was particularly the case for the many neurodiverse people who are attracted to a career in IT, who might struggle with the bureaucracy of gathering the evidence required for registration and presenting it in the right way. New advisory board member Ben Argo, who works on accessibility, agreed with this.
But he said some DDaT workers will face a more basic hurdle: not having one of the qualifications required by the professional bodies. As a neurodivergent individual, he said he’d picked a focused degree, web design, which is not recognised by the BCS. An equivalent degree in computer science would be.
Entrepreneur Ravi Kumar argued the whole professionalism agenda needs to start even earlier, in schools. “The NHS and bodies like the BCS should be going into schools so that in ten or 15-years’ time we have a pipeline of people coming through with the right qualifications and mindset.”
Will said that while the BCS does work with schools and apprenticeship providers, there is more to be done. As several members of the advisory board noted, lots of children want to be doctors and nurses; rather fewer want to be digital health professionals.
The vendor agenda
Of course, it’s not just the NHS that needs DDaT workers. Suppliers need them as well, and Will said one of his current “hobby horses” is to get people working for suppliers to register. “We should expect those working with us in companies to demonstrate professional capability,” he argued.
David Hancock, a consultant and integration expert who had a long career working for EPR and shared care record vendors, agreed, but wondered how this could be enforced. Will argued this should be one of the easier challenges to solve, because “it can be done through the contracting process.”
However, David came back that this would only be the case “if it is seen as important” as “otherwise, it will be like my specialised subject of interoperability: it will get pushed down the evaluation criteria.”
James Norman, another consultant who has worked on both the NHS and the supplier side, said he didn’t want to put another burden on SMEs; even if individuals, not companies, are expected to register. “We want them to get a foot in, but if we start making it harder to do that, they will get pushed away.”
Culture eats registration for breakfast
Sam Neville, a working chief nursing information officer, said suppliers weren’t the only challenge. She told the discussion she was seeing a lot of push-back from the NHS. “I am hearing: ‘Why should I do this?’ and ‘I have done my job for ten-years, why should I have to prove myself to you?’” she said.
Andy Kinnear, a former NHS CIO and long-standing advocate for professionalism, raised the same point in a slightly different way. NHS England has decided to push professionalism through the 10-Year Health Plan, he said, but will that be enough to “change the culture?”
“We have spent the last ten years building the infrastructure for professionalism,” he argued, “but now we need to use it. The mandate pushes us that way, but will it work?” Will acknowledged that culture is an issue, because even though professionalism has been discussed for a long-time, it is still a relatively new concept on the ground.
“If you are a clinician, or an accountant, or if, like my daughter, you are training to be a solicitor, you are used to doing exams to get a licence to practice and then progress,” he said. “We have been lucky in IT, in one way, that we have not had to do that. You get in, and you keep going.”
Having said that, he said there are signs of change, with FEDIP registrations rising, albeit slowly. And DDaT workers only have to look around to see how professionalism helps colleagues to progress their careers and secure the attention of their boards.
Professional silos and common understanding
Jason Broch, a working GP and clinical IT leader, was somewhat sceptical about the status argument. “There is nothing about professionalism that will change the conversation between a CIO and a CFO,” he suggested. Finance is always going to win.
To change board and operational behaviours, he argued, something else is needed. “A common understanding” that the job of professionals working in the NHS is to improve services and “common methodologies and training” in how to deliver on that.
“If we just professionalise in digital, we risk creating another silo,” he said. “Until there is commonality of understanding, we will not get to where we want to be.” Will saw his point, but argued there is an opportunity for digital to lead in this area.
Digital is already a “profession of professions” in which people with backgrounds as different as cyber security, clinical informatics, and data wrangling work together, he said, “so we can shape the change we want to see.”
Other board members argued that digital could help to define the common body of knowledge that professionals need to work together effectively, and the soft skills required.
Dylan Roberts, another new member of the advisory board, with background in NHS and local government described this as combining: “The ying of leadership, resilience, presentation, coaching, influencing and negotiating, combined with the yang of CDIO professional skills.”
The opportunity is now
The professionalism agenda has come a long way in ten-years. It has gone from being a fairly defensive response to the status enjoyed by the medical profession, to an expression of the importance of digital to trust operations, patient safety, and reform.
A lot of the basic groundwork for qualifications, career progression, and governance has been laid, and a mandate for registration has been set. Yes, there are some gnarly issues around recruitment, education, and career progression to sort out.
Yes, the professional bodies and FEDIP need to look at their offers and see whether the complex cross-registration process can be streamlined. And yes, there’s a job to be done to win the hearts and minds of the frontline DDaT workforce.
But Will argued digital needs to keep going, because professionalism matters now, as much as ever. “It is not just that it is how we demonstrate, as individuals, that we are competent in our roles,” he said, “it is how we secure status with boards and with policy makers.
“We want to be able to drive strategy, instead of having the centre to do strategy to us. Professionalism can give us a voice in the DHS and think-tanks, where decisions get made.” As chair, Nicola said she could sum this up as Four Cs. “It is about having a consistent, collective approach to building credibility and confidence at the highest level.”